Renouncing U.S. Citizenship
sumption that a U.S. citizen intends to
retain citizenship when she performs some
of the acts listed in INA Section 349, such
as naturalizing in a foreign state, accepting
non-policy-level employment with a foreign state, or subscribing to a routine oath
of allegiance to a foreign state. 24
If the U.S. citizen has performed any of
the potentially expatriating acts, such as
acquiring another citizenship, and in doing
so intended to relinquish citizenship,
she may appear before a U.S. consular
officer to document this fact. The former
citizen will fill out a form and sign a voluntary relinquishment statement. 25 If the
Department of State approves the finding
that the former U.S. citizen had relinquished citizenship, the Department issues
a Certificate of Loss of Nationality
(“CLN”), which is sent to the former U.S.
citizen, together with that person’s cancelled U.S. passport. 26 The CLN will state
that citizenship was lost at the time the
expatriating act was performed.
U.S. authorities do not always let the
citizen leave easily, as demonstrated by one
of our recent cases. Our client was born in
the United States while his parents, both
British, were in graduate school. He left
the United States at the age of 5 months
and returned with his parents to Britain. As
an adult, he never renewed the U.S. passport his parents had obtained for him.
While studying at Cambridge, he joined
the University’s Royal Naval Reserve unit
as a midshipman—the lowest commissioned officer post. (Serving as a commissioned or non-commissioned officer in the
armed forces of a foreign state is one of the
acts specified in INA § 349(a) as a potentially expatriating act. Notably, it is not one
of the acts as to which the administrative
presumption of intent to retain citizenship
applies.) Believing that he had thereby
abandoned his U.S. citizenship, he thereafter behaved consistently with the belief
that he was no longer a U.S. citizen. He
did not file U.S. tax returns, never voted in
a U.S. election, did not hold a U.S. passport, and in fact travelled a total of 22
times to the United States on his U.K.
passport. 27 In 2011, fearing that the United
States might still consider him a citizen, he
applied to formalize his relinquishment of
U.S. citizenship as of the date more than
10 years earlier on which he joined the
Royal Naval Reserve.
After a brief telephone interview, the
consular officer denied his application to
document his expatriation, stating that
midshipman was not an officer position. We
challenged this administratively and finally,
several months later, received the following
e-mail from the Department of State,
which sets out the Department’s method
for analyzing these cases:
in the United States and assuming that
you can confirm his use of a UK pass-
port to enter the United States, he has
established by the preponderance of
the evidence, as required by INA
Section 349(b), that he has expatriated
himself by virtue of his service as a
non-commissioned officer in the
British Navy. In sum, it appears that []
has voluntarily committed a statutory
act of expatriation with the intention
of relinquishing his U.S. citizenship.
It appears that you have documentation from the British Navy confirming
that [] was in fact a non-commissioned
officer. Service as such is a threshold
statutory act of expatriation (INA
Section 349(a)( 3)(B)). Section 349(b)
of the INA presumes that he acted voluntarily. The only issue that must be
addressed is one of intent. According
to [State Department records], []’s last
passport expired in 1990 [more than
20 years from the date of the e-mail].
Given the fact that he has not voted
He was then allowed to go to the Embassy
in early 2012 and document that he had
relinquished his citizenship as of the date
almost 14 years earlier when he had joined
the Royal Naval Reserve.
THE ONE
PLACE TO FIND
ALL
LAWYERS
IN ARIZONA
THE ONLY PLACE
TO FIND: n alphabetical listings n complete contact information geographically cross-indexed by city, town, state, country The Only Place
FREE TO MEMBERS
To order additional copies: azbar.org/membership/membershipdirectory